| Jarrow Roofing 2 - 4 Northallerton Town | 24/04/2010 | Read |
| Birtley 0 - 3 Northallerton Town | 20/04/2010 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 0 - 4 Stokesley | 17/04/2010 | Read |
| Whitehaven 4 - 3 Northallerton Town | 13/04/2010 | Read |
| Sunderland RCA 2 - 0 Northallerton Town | 10/04/2010 | Read |
| Guisborough Town 1 - 0 Northallerton Town | 27/03/2010 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 3 - 3 York City | 24/03/2010 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 0 - 0 Whickham | 20/03/2010 | Read |
| Thornaby 1- 2 Northallerton Town | 13/03/2010 | Read |
| Thornaby 3 - 2 Northallerton Town | 09/03/2010 | Read |
| Team Northumbria 0 - 1 Northallerton Town | 02/03/2010 | Read |
| Seaham Red Star 2 Northallerton Town 3 | 27/02/2010 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1 - 2 Marske Utd | 20/02/2010 | Read |
| Northalleton Town 3 - 1 Scarborough Athletic | 17/02/2010 | Read |
| Hebburn 1 - 1 Northallerton Town | 13/02/2010 | Read |
| Brandon Utd 0 - 4 Northallerton Town | 10/02/2010 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 5 - 0 Gilford Park | 06/02/2010 | Read |
| Scarborough Town 0 - 3 Northallerton Town | 27/01/2010 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1 - 2 North Shields | 23/01/2010 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 2 - 1 Darlington R A | 20/01/2010 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 3 - 4 Jarrow Roofing | 12/12/2009 | Read |
| Whicham 1 - 3 Northallerton Town | 09/12/2009 | Read |
| Stokesley 5 - Northallertonn Town | 05/12/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1-1 Sunderland RCA | 29/11/2009 | Read |
| Newton Aycliffe 3 - 3 Northallerton Town | 21/11/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 0 - 4 Guisborough Town | 14/11/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 3 - 0 Hebburn Town | 11/11/2009 | Read |
| Whiskham 0 - 1 Northallerton Town | 07/11/2009 | Read |
| Ashington FC (P) 2-2 Northallerton Town | 03/11/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 2-2 Thornaby | 31/10/2009 | Read |
| Crook Town 2-4 Northallerton Town | 24/10/2009 | Read |
| Marske United 1-1 Northallerton Town | 10/10/2009 | Read |
| Crook Town 2 - 0 Northallerton Town | 03/10/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1-2 Crook Town | 30/09/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 2-1 Team Northumbria | 19/09/2009 | Read |
| Gillford Park 2-1 Northallerton Town | 12/09/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 3-0 Birtley Town | 05/09/2009 | Read |
| Darlington RA 1-5 Northallerton Town | 31/08/2009 | Read |
| Washington 2 - 2 Northallerton Town | 29/08/2009 | Read |
| North Shields 4-1 Northallerton Town | 25/08/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 2-1 Team Northumbria | 22/08/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1 - 2 Shildon | 19/08/2009 | Read |
| Shildon AFC 0-0 Northallerton Town | 15/08/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 2-2 Whitehaven Amateurs | 12/08/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 2-2 Brandon United | 08/08/2009 | Read |
| Darlington Croft 1 - 5 Northallerton Town | 03/08/2009 | Read |
