| Sunderland Nissan 6 - 1 Northallerton Town | 02/05/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 0 Whitley Bay 2 | 29/04/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1 - 5 Bishop Auckland | 25/04/2009 | Read |
| Bedlington Terriers 3 - 2 Northallerton Town | 18/04/2009 | Read |
| Penrith 3 - 0 Northallerton Town | 13/04/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 2 - 4 Sunderland Nissan | 11/04/2009 | Read |
| Ryton 5 - 2 Northallerton Town | 04/04/2009 | Read |
| Morpeth 1 - 2 Northallerton Town | 31/03/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1 - 5 Ashington | 28/03/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1 - 2 West Allotment Celtic | 25/03/2009 | Read |
| Shildon 5 - 1 Northallerton Town | 18/03/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1- 1 Seaham Red Star | 14/03/2009 | Read |
| West Auckland Town 0 - 1 Northallerton Town | 07/03/2009 | Read |
| Consett 2 - 0 Northallerton Town | 04/03/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 4 - 2 Tow Law | 28/02/2009 | Read |
| Bishop Auckland 1 - 0 Northallerton Town | 25/02/2009 | Read |
| Newcastle Benfield 6 - 1 Northallerton Town | 21/02/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1 - 5 Dunston Federation | 11/02/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1 - 1 B'ham Synthonia | 31/01/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 3 - 1 South Shields | 17/01/2009 | Read |
| Chester Le Street 3 -1 Northallerton Town | 03/01/2009 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 0 - 1 Billingham Town | 20/12/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 0 - 3 Bedlington Terriers | 22/11/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 3 - 1 Thornaby | 12/11/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 4 - 5 Ryton FC | 08/11/2008 | Read |
| Ashington AFC 3-1 Northallerton Town | 01/11/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 0 - 2 Newcastle Benfield BP | 29/10/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 3 -2 Spennymoor | 25/10/2008 | Read |
| Seaham Red Star 0 - 2 Northallerton Town | 18/10/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 0 - 3 West Auckland | 11/10/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton 2 - 0 Consett | 04/10/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 0 - 4 Dunston | 01/10/2008 | Read |
| Tow Law 1 - 0 Northallerton Town | 27/09/2008 | Read |
| Whitley Bay 6 - 3 Northallerton Town | 23/09/2008 | Read |
| Dunston Fed 3 - 0 Northallerton Town | 20/09/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 4 - 2 Sunderland RCA | 16/09/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 2 - 1 Morpeth Town | 13/09/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 0 - 1 Marske Utd | 10/09/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1 - 1 Chester Le Street | 05/09/2008 | Read |
| Spennymoor Utd 3 - 1 Northallerton Town | 30/08/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1 - 2 Penrith | 25/08/2008 | Read |
| Billingham Town 1 -1 Northallerton Town | 23/08/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1 - 1 Shildon | 20/08/2008 | Read |
| Northallerton Town 1 - 3 Whitley Bay | 16/08/2008 | Read |
| South Shields 3 - 2 Northallerton Town | 12/08/2008 | Read |
| Billingham Synthonia 4 - 0 Northallerton Town | 09/08/2008 | Read |
